First of all the good. This jacket looks great. One of those coats that you could easily wear on a business casual day at work, and then the next day on a hike in the mountains. Very versatile aesthetically.I found it to be a bit small. I'm 5'9 190 lbs with broad shoulders and a 32" waist. I found the L was nice on my shoulders but looked sloppily large around my waist. So I went with a Medium. It was slightly small for a M (but not inappropriately so), and the light stretch in the material (which I love) made it acceptable and fit nicely. Kinda gives it a tailored look when wearing it to work, and on a hike you want layers close to your body to hold in the warm air. So not a bad design.But now time for the huge flaw. The felt lining. It's soft. And it feels great. And If you're wearing it with just a T-shirt it's awesome. BUT if you're wearing it with any cotton winter clothing (sweater, Henley, etc), the lining sticks to the shirt and makes in a pain to put on. And since it's a midweight coat, that's what I'm going to be wearing under it 90% of the time. Just seemed like they didn't think through the functionality of this lining.